Does your company still need a COO? | The CEO Magazine

Go Back
Does your company still need a COO? | The CEO Magazine
The COO role can be critical to a company’s success, but what happens when the business outgrows the need for one? For CEOs and boards, knowing when to retain, redefine or remove the role is a question of organizational effectiveness, not individual performance.
AI-generated summary

A COO is often appointed at moments of organizational strain or anticipated transition. A company has grown beyond the CEO’s capacity to oversee everything. Execution is uneven. An acquisition has created a difficult integration challenge, or the board wants to prepare a possible successor.

In each case, the role is created for a reason. Difficulty arises if the reason disappears while the position remains. That possibility makes it worth periodically asking, “Does our company still need a COO?” Ask it as a question of organizational design. How the incumbent has performed is a separate matter.

After studying the role for more than two decades, we have found there is no standard COO job. Some run the operating core; others lead a transformation or partner with a founder. A company doesn’t need a COO because it is large or growing. It needs one when a consequential set of responsibilities cannot be handled through the existing allocation of executive work.

Start with why the role was created

Reconstruct the original rationale. Was the COO appointed so the CEO could spend more time with investors and the board? Was the company struggling to execute across business units? Did a founder need a partner to build the systems required for scale? Was the role created to integrate an acquisition, lead a transformation or prepare a successor?

The answers matter because each rationale implies a different definition of success. A COO hired to impose operating discipline should not be judged by the same standard as one hired to help a founder professionalize the company.

Trouble comes when the company’s needs change, but the COO does not.

Trouble comes when the company’s needs change, but the COO does not. The integration finishes or business unit leaders grow strong enough to coordinate their own operations. Yet the COO keeps supervising work that no longer requires enterprise-level attention.

That gradually turns a useful role into an expensive relay station. Decisions travel up to the COO and back down to executives who could have made them. The CEO and COO sit in the same meetings, review the same information, weigh in on the same decisions. The COO hasn’t stopped working, but the role’s original purpose has weakened.

Look for an execution gap

The strongest continuing case for a COO is a persistent gap between the CEO’s agenda and the organization’s capacity to execute it.

That gap is likely when the CEO must manage growing external demands, from AI to geopolitics to an expanding C-suite, while the organization carries heavy internal interdependence. Many strategic initiatives require coordination across functions whose leaders answer to different incentives and time horizons.

Here the COO does more than run the business. The COO converts strategy into an execution plan and ensures that decisions taken at the top reach the ground.

The strongest continuing case for a COO is a persistent gap between the CEO’s agenda and the organization’s capacity to execute it.

A company may still need a COO even when operations look smooth, because coordination that succeeds is quieter than strategy that gets announced. The question is whether they run smoothly because the organization has become capable without the COO or because the COO is doing integrative work no-one else sees.

Noting that the COO is busy proves little; most senior executives can fill any amount of time. The board and CEO should name the decisions and relationships that would weaken if the role disappeared. If they cannot, the case for keeping the position deserves scrutiny.

Is the role building capacity or creating dependence?

A good COO makes the organization more capable. Over time, business-unit and functional leaders get better at coordinating across boundaries and translating enterprise priorities into operating decisions.

The opposite can happen. The COO becomes the person through whom every important issue must pass. Executives bring disagreements to the COO instead of settling them with one another. The CEO relies on the COO to interpret the organization. That may produce short-term reliability at the cost of long-term fragility. An indispensable COO can be a sign that too little capability has been built elsewhere.

The point matters most when the COO was appointed to repair weak execution. Early on, direct intervention may be necessary: establishing routines, stepping into failing initiatives. But intervention should give way to institutional capacity. Otherwise, the company stays dependent on the executive instead of benefiting from a stronger operating system.

One useful test is to ask what has become possible without the COO’s direct involvement. If the answer is ‘very little’, the problem may lie with the role, the person or the team around it.

A board that can’t describe what would weaken if the COO role vanished, has already answered the question.

Eliminating the role can make sense when its defining work is finished, when other executives can absorb its responsibilities or when the position simply adds a layer between the CEO and the business. It can also make sense when the role has become a substitute for fixing something else.

A company should not need a COO to compensate for weak functional leaders or poorly defined decision rights. Installing a capable executive above those problems conceals them without resolving them.

Succession is another decision point. If the COO was appointed as the likely next CEO, the company must eventually advance the executive or reconsider the role. Leaving a credible successor waiting breeds frustration and organizational uncertainty. Promoting a COO merely because the seat was a staging ground can mean installing a CEO whose real strength was being an operating partner.

Removing the position does not remove its work. Before removal, the company must decide who will integrate enterprise initiatives and translate strategy into coordinated action. Splitting those duties among several executives can work, but only if the resulting accountabilities are explicit.

The role must continue to earn its place

For some companies, the COO role has never been more relevant. The demands on CEOs have expanded, and the distance between announcing a strategy and realizing it remains wide. A well-designed COO role supplies integration and leadership capacity the organization would otherwise lack.

But relevance does not establish necessity in a particular company. Some companies clearly need a COO and some do not. The question is whether your company faces critical, enduring responsibilities that a COO can carry better than any alternative arrangement.

If the answer is yes, define those responsibilities and give the COO the authority and access to carry them out. If it is no, redesign the organization rather than keep a role whose purpose has passed. A board that can’t describe what would weaken if the COO role vanished, has already answered the question – it just hasn’t acted yet.

Opinions expressed by The CEO Magazine contributors are their own.

Stephen Miles

Contributor Collective Member

Stephen Miles is one of the world’s top business coaches, supporting CEOs and COOs across the globe. He is involved in advancing C-suite and board dynamics research in collaboration with the Stanford Graduate School of Business and is Co-Founder of the New CEO Program at the University of Melbourne. Stephen has also authored several bestselling books on executive-level leadership and hosts the ‘C-Suite Intelligence’ podcast. Find out more at https://miles-group.com/teams/stephen-miles/

Back to top