Go Back
Brand reinvention is essential for growth, but today change has become a battlefield. Here's how to safely and successfully navigate change in an era of culture wars, bots and weaponized attention.
AI-generated summary

At some point in every company’s life cycle, the risk of standing still becomes greater than the risk of transformation. The logo looks a little tired, the product a little dated, the customers a little gray.

Reinvention can be risky. Many of the trends that trigger the need for transformation are inherently polarizing. Carving out new growth paths without alienating loyal customers or core channel partners, adapting to affordability, tech trends or shifting social expectations – all without being misread or mischaracterized – is no easy feat.

Now layer on a new threat: activist investors and political provocateurs, armed to the teeth with bots, looking to torpedo your transformation before it achieves liftoff.

Even the most well-considered corporate shifts are being challenged and politically weaponized. Not because the move was poorly timed or strategically flawed, but because someone saw an opportunity to hijack the narrative – and had the digital tools to do it.

Reinvention can be risky. Many of the trends that trigger the need for transformation are inherently polarizing.

I speak from experience. Not too long ago, our firm was involved in a Cracker Barrel transformation effort that had all the right ingredients: a strong business collaboration, operational alignment, cultural sensitivity and early signs of success. But a press release about a refreshed brand and marketing campaign became the target of political influencers and coordinated bot networks. What began as a step forward in relevance became, for a moment, a flashpoint in the culture wars.

By the time the President started talking about it, the client realized they underappreciated how deeply customers valued the traditional branding. The transformation stalled. And for me, one undeniable truth seemed to bubble up from the wreckage: it’s not enough to have the right intentions.

That’s because business leaders charting a transformation are no longer just navigating strategic and operational complexity. You’re also contending with a landscape of activist stakeholders, social media distortion, bot-driven amplification and political opportunism. Sometimes the pushback is rooted in nostalgia. More often, it’s manufactured by people who have no connection to your business – and no interest in understanding it, much less preserving it.

That doesn’t mean you stop evolving. It means you need to evolve smarter.

Begin with what you must protect

The smartest transformation strategies don’t start with what needs to change. They start with what must be preserved.

That includes customer relationships, channel dynamics, hero products and service rituals – whatever elements are truly non-negotiable for your current business to remain functional as you build the next one. Think of it as clarity around your core.

The smartest transformation strategies don’t start with what needs to change. They start with what must be preserved.

But in today’s climate, you also need clarity around cultural risk. What are the symbols, behaviors and messages that may carry more emotional or political weight than you realize? What elements of your identity might be interpreted – rightly or wrongly – as a signal to one side or another?

These aren’t reasons to avoid those elements. They’re reasons to plan for every contingency surrounding them, communicate carefully and be intentional in your sequencing.

Map the risk and hijack potential

Before you launch a change effort, scenario-plan around it like you would a cyber threat.

• Identify the cultural landmines in your company’s radius – political flashpoints, racial sensitivities, gender perceptions – and keep a safe distance.

• Avoid getting forced into false ‘either/or’ trade-offs – don’t disenfranchise anyone.

• List the external actors who are most likely to misrepresent this move.

• What narrative would they craft and how fast could it spread?

• How could social media bots or coordinated networks amplify it?

• What internal vulnerabilities would make your team freeze or fracture under pressure?

Think of it as pre-crisis PR or strategic foresight. Whatever you call it, it’s becoming a board-level competency.

One of the most important questions a CEO can ask before a major transformation goes live is: “What’s the hijack risk?” And if your answer is “We hadn’t thought about that”, you’re already exposed.

Move deliberately and signal when ready

In this environment, sequence matters. Particularly when the changes you’re making could be misunderstood or misrepresented before the results speak for themselves.

Start with brand legacy and then build on it. Redesign the stores. Update the recipe. Test drive the new logo. Internal communication is a must – sandbagging your employees never helped anyone.

But before you spout off in public, get those proof points in hand and bring the story forward with the data, customer impact and operational improvements to back it up.

Build what’s next, but build it with an eye toward unseen dangers.

Announcing your intentions years before consumers see change opens the window to a vast range of pushback. The smarter move? Execute first, build evidence and then share, with confidence and evidence of early success.

As AI becomes both an accelerant and an inhibitor to these backlashes, the path forward will require even greater scenario planning, clarity and a steely spine. Build what’s next, but build it with an eye toward unseen dangers. Know what to protect and who to protect from, and hold steady when the backlash begins.

In this new world, transformation will always carry risk, but none so great as going in unprepared.

Opinions expressed by The CEO Magazine contributors are their own.

Michael Dunn

Contributor Collective Member

Michael Dunn is Chairman and CEO of Prophet and has helped orchestrate the firm’s tremendous growth over the past two decades. This includes expanding the firm’s global presence and enhancing Prophet’s position as the premier growth consultancy committed to helping clients grow in the face of disruption. He also serves as a strategic advisor on client engagements and has relevant expertise in the financial services, healthcare, high-tech, retail, industrial B2B and internet sectors. Michael has co-authored two business books – one focused on brand equity development and the other on marketing effectiveness. Find out more at https://prophet.com/author/michael-dunn/

Back to top